EDITOR’S NOTE: Southern Baptist African American leaders offered diverse perspectives to help churches thrive during current challenges in a virtual town hall  August 25, hosted by the National African American Fellowship of the Southern Baptist Convention (NAAF).
Many of us who are African American Southern Baptists are asked the question, “Why are you Southern Baptist?” Last June in Birmingham at our National African American Fellowship meeting, I preached a sermon  that attempted to address this question. I have adapted that sermon into this article.
If I can borrow from the sentiment of 1 Peter 3:15, when we are asked, “Why are you Southern Baptist?” we should all be able to give a reason and do so with gentleness and kindness.
The question we get is, “As a Black man or Black woman, why are you Southern Baptist?” Let me give you a couple of reasons why this remains a question in the community of color, and then I will share my reasons for being in the Southern Baptist Convention.
The challenges of being Southern Baptist as an African American include:
1) SBC History
The Southern Baptist Convention was founded in May 1845 in Augusta, Georgia, where 293 delegates gathered to break away from the American Baptist Home Mission Society forming a new mission society. The historical fact is that the SBC was born out “. . . of a commitment to preserve and defend slavery” (Matthew J. Hall, Removing the Stain of Racism from the Southern Baptist Convention). Don’t think the Southern Baptists were walking this road alone—there were similar situations among the Presbyterians and Methodists.
2) SBC Heritage
The SBC heritage is that many of our white brothers and sisters were effectively born into the SBC—a heritage passed from their great, great, great Southern Baptist granddaddies. In this heritage the ideologies and symbols of a perpetuated myth include white superiority, manifest destiny, and paternalism. We see this heritage on the names of buildings, revered names in the hallowed halls of agencies and institutions. This revered heritage is a perpetual inference of a mindset that those of a darker hue (Black and Brown) may not be equal and are an infringement upon the heritage for some.
3) SBC Hiring
Recently, an unprecedented number of agency head positions were vacant, along with a couple of other lesser appointments of note. Now, first let me say that all of the selections were filled by men of good reputations, good character, and good qualifications—I know a couple of them personally and they are all good Christian men. But that is not the issue!
The issue is that in a Convention that promotes its diversity and at a time when there were five agency heads vacant, if not one Black, Brown, African-American, Hispanic, Native American, Asian, or Islander is selected, we have a problem in our hiring processes!
I worked in hiring and HR in one of my previous jobs. There is an inherent bias in hiring—in general we tend to hire people like ourselves, because we are comfortable hiring people like ourselves. Unconscious bias toward people who are of the same race, education level, or economic status, and have the same personality, fears, or values, influences who you hire much more than you think.
We need to bring this to the attention of those who have hiring authority. We must be intentional in hiring people who we may not be “racially” comfortable with. Don’t be afraid to hire someone to head an agency who is racially or culturally different! Otherwise, optically, it looks like we are protecting the history and heritage in our hiring.
Again, all the men who were selected are fine and qualified people. We want them to do well, so I take nothing from them. They are all brothers in Christ! But, hear me now: In the SBC, we need Black and Brown faces in high places!
And yet, even with the history, the heritage, and the hiring, I am still unashamedly Southern Baptist!
So let me share why I am Southern Baptist:
1) I am Southern Baptist because I am a CHRISTIAN.
First of all and most of all, I am unashamedly, unabashedly Christian! I am a born-again, baptized believer in the Lord Jesus Christ. I am redeemed and Jesus Christ is my redeemer. I am blood-bought and Christ-sanctified, declared righteous by God through faith in the Lord Jesus Christ. I believe that Jesus died for my sins and rose from the dead on the third day, and through Christ and Christ alone, I have eternal life. I believe that He chose me in Christ Jesus before the foundation of the world!
So before I am Southern Baptist, I am a follower of Jesus Christ. Before I am Black, I am a Christian. At my core and at my center is Christ! He is the reason for the hope that I have.
Let’s not get it confused—being Southern Baptist won’t save you. There is not a Southern Baptist heaven and there is not a Southern Baptist hell. The Southern Baptist Convention is a tool in the mighty hand of God—don’t get it twisted. We bring glory to God, as a Christian movement, in the hands of Almighty God.
God will shake us to make us, to take us to where He wants us. We are in His hands, and the best place to be in the whole wide world is in the hands of Almighty God! I am Southern Baptist because I am a Christian.
2) I am Southern Baptist because of my CHOICE.
Second, I am Southern Baptist because I choose to be Southern Baptist. This is one area where I am pro-choice! Some of my friends may never understand why I have chosen to be Southern Baptist. In 1865 previously enslaved Blacks left the SBC in droves, and not until 1953 did the first Black congregation return. Yes, I choose to be Southern Baptist. The SBC is not a plantation—I can go or stay as I please, but I choose to stay and I choose to be Southern Baptist!
Yes, despite the history, despite the heritage, despite the hirings, despite all of that and more—I still choose to be Southern Baptist. By the way, there is no perfect denomination or convention. If you happen to think you have found one, please by all means don’t join it. Because once you join it, it will not be perfect!
I choose to be Southern Baptist, because we as a Convention have come a mighty, mighty long way! Not that we as a Convention have arrived—we are still becoming—but when I look at the history of the SBC, we’ve come a mighty long way! We’ve got a ways to go, but sure enough you’ve got to say, we’ve come a mighty long way!
I look back at the founding in 1845 by slave holders and slave promoters, promoting white superiority, and from that foundation to the milestone election of Fred Luter as the SBC president in 2012, some 167 years later—God has brought us a mighty long way!
Though change might be slow, it shows that the arc of the moral universe is long, but it is bent toward justice. We can sit down at the table of brotherhood and sisterhood as one through Jesus Christ.
I choose to be Southern Baptist because of the work in missions; the synergy in missions; the disaster relief efforts; the exaltation of Jesus Christ; the Gospel-centeredness; the belief in Christ alone for salvation; the clear presentation of the Gospel; the pro-life beliefs; the belief that the Bible is the authoritative Word of God; the repentance for past sins as a group; and the fact that we are better than when we first began!
I choose to be Southern Baptist because of the high view of Scripture, that we come under the authority of the Scripture that governs our lives. We are not biblically liberal, we are not the prosperity gospel, and we are not heretical in our hermeneutic. Christ is the only way—not one way among many ways, but the only way to salvation!
I choose to be Southern Baptist because I believe that God has His hand on this Convention for such a time as this. He is bringing together white, Black, Asian, Hispanic, African, and Native American, along with people of every tongue, tribe, and nation to be a picture of heaven, to exalt the name of Jesus Christ, and to share the Gospel around the world! We learn from our past and strive to reach higher ground in Christ Jesus.
Admittedly, some days being Southern Baptist is a lot like being married. In marriage not every day is a bowl of cherries—some days it feels like the pits. But you hang in the marriage because that woman or man you married is worth the trouble! My friends, our Southern Baptist Convention is worth the difficult moments. We can do more together than we can by ourselves.
I believe we are America’s best last hope, and we ought to be able to get it together because we’ve got King Jesus on our side! And even when I look back over the last twenty-five years that I’ve been in this Convention and attending the annual meetings, I’ve just got to say, “God has brought us a mighty long way!” Therefore, I am Southern Baptist by choice.
3) I am Southern Baptist because I am CALLED.
The third reason that I am Southern Baptist is because I am called. And this is probably the most compelling reason that I am Southern Baptist. I am Southern Baptist because I feel led by the Lord Jesus Christ to be Southern Baptist—I am Southern Baptist because I have an unshakeable, undeniable, and unequivocal sense of being called to be Southern Baptist. I have felt that this is where God wants us, every spectrum of the color wheel. My friends, I hope that all of us in the SBC feel that this is where the Lord wants us. It may not make sense to some of our friends or family—it will not make sense to our critics—but in the depth of our soul there is something that is the movement of God.
My friends, God is up to something with the SBC. I believe that God has been shaking and shaping our Convention since 1845, to get us to where He wants us and to be all that He wants us to be. We must work cooperatively to reach the world for Jesus Christ—that more men, women, boys, and girls of every hue and every nationality would come to know Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior.
We have got to strive to be one in Christ—loving God and loving one another. We are many different members, but one body in Christ Jesus. When we are one, one body under God, we can sure enough make hell shudder and heaven shout! Despite our history, heritage, and hiring, I am Southern Baptist because I am Christian, because I choose to be, and because I feel called to be.
As part of the Convention I have seven actions that may help all of us as we move forward together. Let us:
- Pray for the further advancement of the Gospel;
- Pray for our SBC leaders and entity leaders;
- Give thanks to God for how far He has brought the SBC;
- Refuse to attack our brothers and sisters through social media;
- Look for opportunities to share and resolve our issues within the SBC family;
- Do all we can do for the sake of the unity in the Body; and
- Understand that we are better together than by ourselves.